It's no secret that I like films. I don't obsess over them very often, but I do like to
think and write about them, which I recognize goes a few steps beyond the usual behavior of just
renting and watching them.
I appreciate that some people watch movies purely for entertainment. That's fine. I do that sometimes. Other times, I watch movies to be challenged, devastated, perplexed, uplifted, shocked, inspired, etc.
A lot of the best movies contain adult content, and are therefore rated R. Most of my family and friends don't watch R-rated movies on principle. That's fine. I do watch R-rated movies. I also read banned books.
Anyway, I digress. Here, in a very particular order (best to worst) are the Best Picture nominees from last year. I feel like I've finally seen enough of them to make an informed (albeit personal) ranking. You should see the ones at the top - although I warn you, they are not for kids.
127 Hours
I have written a bit about this film already. Suffice it to say, this was my favorite film of 2010, and is probably up there with
Apollo 13 in terms of movies that make me proud to be a human being. As with
Black Swan, I initially avoided this film because I was afraid the content would be too disturbing. Instead, I found it enlightening and uplifting in ways that few other works of art have matched for me.
This adventure/drama/thriller has some ingenious cinematography, astonishing acting from James Franco, a brilliant score, and an absolutely thrilling message. Everyone should see this movie.
True Grit
I will never understand the ratings system. How can an innocent little film like
The King's Speech be restricted to viewers over the age of 17, while the intensely violent and harrowing western
True Grit is deemed suitable for kids? Granted, I think it's a remarkable film. The Cohen brothers are geniuses when it comes to constructing a scene. The characters are delightful, the plot is satisfying, the filming is gorgeous, and the writing is hilarious and touching. But its violent content is far more disturbing than a few F-words in a speech therapy session, and it should have been rated R.
The King's Speech
This biopic is an utter delight from beginning to end. I disagree with those who call it tepid, made-for-TV drama. It's a brilliant character study, well-written and superbly acted, and makes a relatively simple story crackle with texture and urgency.
I found a few things to nit-pick, however. The cinematography was distracting, particularly in the early therapy scenes. Perhaps this was for a reason - to put the audience on edge? - but all it did was annoy me. Also, I felt like Helena Bonham Carter's character was flat as a pancake. I mean, her husband is suddenly the King of England, and she has a chance to buoy him up. What does she say?
I was afraid to marry you because I thought this would happen, and now it's happening. How she delivers this without a hint of irony is beyond me.
But, despite a few minor distractions, the film tells a great story in a really endearing, low-key kind of British way. It's definitely worthy of its Oscar wins, though I would have picked a different Best Pic.
Black Swan
As with
Pan's Labyrinth, and a precious few other films, I have been obsessively terrified of
Black Swan ever since seeing the trailer in cinemas. It got right under my skin and stayed there. Something about the twirling ballerina leg in the music box. Yikes. But when I heard about 'the scene,' and remembered that it was a Darren Aronofski film, I kind of decided not to see it. I knew the film would go places I wasn't totally comfortable with. But, eventually, curiosity got the best of me and I rented it.
Black Swan is an exploration of themes that are very close to me. Almost too close for comfort. No, I'm not an obsessive ballerina striving for perfection, and no I don't have psychotic breaks from reality, and no I don't compulsively scratch myself. But the part of me that is a performer, the part of me that feels lonely and claustrophobic, the part of me that desperately wants to excel, the part of me that fears my own demons... they all found a lot to relate to in this film.
Of course,
Black Swan takes these themes to their darkest, most troubling extremes. There's something cathartic in that. And something dangerously seductive. But it isn't simply dark for the sake of being dark. It tells a story that undermines your grasp on reality, and sanity. I squirmed, I jumped, I gasped, at times I turned away, but I was completely enthralled. Gripping performances, merciless direction, and a shocking script make this brave film well worth watching.
The Social Network
I suppose this film is perfect. I can't think of a single flaw (apart from Rashida Jones's awful last line), and it's certainly relevant, epochal, the stuff of myth. But... despite its super-smart dialogue and slick cinematography, I just don't find myself empathizing with the characters. A bunch of rich kids arguing over who came up with what idea first... Yeah, I'm simplifying, but... it just doesn't have the urgency, the immediacy, the universality of some of the other Best Pic contenders - at least I didn't feel it.
Toy Story 3
This one was actually a bit of a disappointment for me. I felt like it was emotionally manipulative, inappropriately scary, and generally pretty gloomy. That being said, it was also genuinely funny, moving, and nostalgic. I enjoyed it, but I didn't love it. I think it was superior to
How to Train Your Dragon in terms of animation quality, but
Dragon's story was infinitely better. Sad as it makes me to say it, I feel like Disney·Pixar may have peaked with
Wall·E and
UP.
The Fighter
I don't think I would have seen this gritty drama on my own. I don't much care for boxing films, as I tend to find them more formulaic than perhaps any other genre. But, as it happened, I went to see
The Fighter in London with a few friends, one of whom actually had a small speaking part in the movie! I loved the cracking dialogue and the sublime acting (particularly from Melissa Leo). I felt very empathetic with the characters, agonizing over their alienating, dysfunctional behavior. In the end, though, I have to say this film left little of a lasting impression. It was engrossing, but perhaps too loose and rambling to make a major impact.
Inception
Although I love this flick, its director, its cast, and especially its originality, I have to say I left the theatre feeling a bit let down. I had spent the whole film waiting for the rug to be pulled out from under me - waiting for reality to shift, for the stakes to jump, for the game to change - but it didn't happen. The conceit was explained, ad nauseam, and then it was deployed. Simple.
Again, I love this film. Seriously, I do. But, these are DREAMS! Anything is possible! ANYTHING! Why oh why does the dream world need to be so rigidly naturalistic? And why oh why is Cobb's subconscious city so bland? He and his wife spent a lifetime building... identical gray high-rises?
What I resent about this film is that it could have taken the
Memento-style destabilization of reality to a whole new level. Instead, it took a step back, and catered to a summer audience who could hardly be bothered to put two and two together on their own. As a result, it was a linear crowd pleasing action flick, disguised as a psychological thriller. Still, I love this film.
Winter's Bone
This quiet Sundance flick is impressive, but ultimately uninspired. Its disturbing heart of darkness is nearly rendered believable by solid performances, but even good acting cannot completely redeem its loose, sometimes incoherent script.
The Kids Are All Right
I haven't seen this one, and haven't had any desire to. Is it any good?